How We Research Gutter Guards

Gutter guard reviews have a credibility problem. Many of them promise “hands-on testing” and then show no photos, no numbers and no method; others are written by the companies selling the guards. We’d rather tell you exactly what we do, what we don’t, and where every number comes from.

In short: we verify every fact against a source we’ve read in full, and we credit other people’s tests to the people who ran them. We don’t run our own lab tests or collect our own quotes, so we never claim to: product findings come from the independent tests we cite, and prices from published surveys and cost guides.

What we verify on every page

  • Manufacturer documents first. Product specs, warranty terms and availability come from the company’s current website or warranty document, and we note the date we checked. When a claim we used to make is no longer on the company’s site, we take it out.
  • Independent testing, credited. When another publication has tested a product hands-on, we report what it found and name it, with a link.
  • Buyer surveys and cost guides, with context. Prices come from published buyer surveys and contractor cost guides. We say what each number measures (installed or materials only, average or range).
  • Primary sources for rules and safety. Building code requirements come from the International Residential Code text itself; ladder safety from NIOSH and the American Ladder Institute; your cancellation rights from the Federal Trade Commission’s rule.
  • Every source listed. Each page ends with its sources, and we keep a running internal log of how each one was checked.

Field notes from our founder

This site was founded by Chris, a contractor in South Texas with more than 10 years’ experience installing and maintaining gutter guards of all shapes and sizes. Where he wrote about a product from experience, his observations appear in “From the field” boxes, checked against current product information, and limited to what he actually said.

What we never do

  • Claim to have tested something we haven’t.
  • Invent ratings, scores or customer stories.
  • Let a company pay for a better position in a review.
  • Leave out a warranty limitation because it’s inconvenient for a brand.

How we make money, and how we keep it separate from our reviews, is on our disclosure page. Our wider rules are in our editorial policy.

Gutter reminders, right before the season

When to clean, what to check before the leaves fall and the storms come, and our new guides. Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.

See our privacy policy.