How to Fix Leaky Gutters: Seams, Corners, End Caps and Holes
A leaky gutter announces itself in the same spot every storm: a steady drip off one corner, a dark streak down the siding below a seam, a little crater in the mulch under an end cap. It’s rarely the gutter itself that’s failed. It’s the sealant at a joint that’s dried out, cracked or let go.
Most gutter leaks are at joints: end caps, splices between sections, corner miters and the outlet where the downspout connects. Every one of those connections needs to be sealed (Family Handyman), and resealing them is a cheap afternoon job. Holes in the gutter itself can be patched with matching metal; rust holes in steel gutters usually mean it’s time to replace that section (This Old House).
Find the leak
Leaks are easiest to find with water, not by eye. On a dry day, run a garden hose into the gutter at the high end and watch from below. Mark each drip with tape or chalk. Check:
- End caps at each end of a run.
- Splices where two gutter sections overlap (sectional gutters have many; seamless gutters only have them at corners).
- Miters at inside and outside corners.
- The drop outlet where the downspout attaches.
- Spike holes where old hangers went through the gutter.
If water is coming down behind the gutter rather than through it, the gutter isn’t leaking. It needs a gutter apron or drip edge at the roof edge so water can’t run between the roof and the gutter (Family Handyman).
Reseal joints, end caps and outlets
- Clean the joint completely. Scrape out old sealant and debris. For aluminum, wash the area with denatured alcohol (This Old House); wipe the mating surfaces with acetone before sealing (This Old House).
- Let it dry. Sealant won’t bond to a wet seam (Family Handyman).
- Use sealant made for gutters, and keep the tube warm in cold weather so it flows (Family Handyman).
- Run a continuous bead across the joint on the inside of the gutter and smooth it so water can’t get under the edge.
- Seal the drop outlet to the gutter with seam sealer (Family Handyman).
- Test with a hose once it has cured.
Patch holes and rust spots
For a hole or a small rusted area in an otherwise sound gutter, This Old House’s method (This Old House):
- Clean out debris and wire-brush the area.
- Cut out any rust with aviation snips.
- Spread roofing cement a few inches past the hole on all sides.
- Press a metal patch into the cement, trimmed slightly smaller than the cemented area.
Match the metal. Use aluminum flashing to patch an aluminum gutter. Mixing metals encourages electrolytic corrosion (This Old House); for the same reason, Family Handyman warns that galvanized steel will corrode aluminum (Family Handyman).
Repair tape is the quick alternative for rusty spots or open seams on a sound gutter: scrape off old tar or caulk, wire-brush, use an adhesive primer on heavy rust, and overlap long seams by at least 1 inch and end seams by 4 inches (Family Handyman).
When to stop patching
- Steel gutters with rust holes: replace the section rather than patching (This Old House).
- Rust, cracks or sagging in several places: that points to replacement over repair (This Old House).
- Leaks that keep returning at the same seams on an old sectional system: seamless gutters only have joints at the corners and outlets, which removes most of the places leaks start.
A professional gutter repair runs roughly $75 to $625, about $350 on average, according to This Old House (This Old House).
Prevent the next leak
- Keep gutters clean. Wet debris sitting against a joint holds water there and speeds up corrosion.
- Keep the slope right (at least ¼ inch per 10 feet toward the downspout) so water doesn’t sit against seams (This Old House).
- Check hangers. A sagging section flexes the joints next to it and breaks the sealant. Replace loose spikes with modern hangers or gutter screws, and fix rotten fascia before rehanging (This Old House; This Old House).
- Look once a year, ideally with a hose test in fall before the leaves come down.
Compare installed prices near you
Free quotes from up to 3 local gutter guard installers. No obligation.
Sources
- This Old House, “Repairing Damaged Gutters” (May 2026). thisoldhouse.com
- This Old House, “How To Fix Sagging Gutters” (May 2026). thisoldhouse.com
- Family Handyman, “25 Ways to Fix Gutter Leaks and Other Roofing Issues” (October 2024). familyhandyman.com